BBC puts human face to poverty

BBC Northern Ireland Small Logo

Spotlight presented a life swap with a social conscience when it followed two women for a week, one from a wealthy background, the other living on benefits.

Theresa Agnew (left) and Brenda Shankey meet Danny Kennedy MLA

Theresa Agnew (left) and Brenda Shankey meet Danny Kennedy MLA

One of the spin-offs was discussions about poverty on other BBC programmes, including Nolan and Talkback.

Theresa Agnew, a community activist and single mother from Armagh, struggling to get out of the poverty trap, swapped lives with successful Belfast businesswoman Brenda Shankey.

The programme Life Swap: Diamonds and Dole was prompted by the recent Stormont report that admitted that 10% of children in Northern Ireland are living in severe poverty.

It also comes at a time when the voluntary and community sector, anxious that the NI Executive has not yet agreed an anti-poverty strategy, is launching a new campaign for urgent action to tackle the problem.

Before trading places, Brenda said:

"I don’t know anybody in poverty in this day and age. I would like to see what the truth is in that environment".

She added that her perception was that people did not have to live in poverty.

Watch online

You can watch the programme online using the BBC iPlayer until Monday 18 February

Brenda and her two young children went to live in Theresa’s council home on an estate in Armagh, exchanging all the trappings of a comfortable life for the reality of surviving on the breadline.

The prospect of no money, lack of transport and limited access to shopping reduced Brenda to tears – not to talk of the immediate problem of moving into a house that was damp and cold and had an empty gas tank for the cooker.

Brenda admitted.

“I run three successful businesses, I work really hard, but this has just drained me.”

Theresa and her teenage daughter, Edana, moved into Brenda's large family home in Belfast. Before arriving she said:

“I’ve met all kinds of people, met middle class people, they have got a very poor impression of working class people, that we are riff raff.”

Theresa was overcome with the amount of money she suddenly has available to spend on luxury items, expressing guilt at having beauty treatments, a new wardrobe and expensive hair styling.

While adapting to her comfortable new life, Theresa said:

“It seems awful to me…to spend £120 on a hairdo when people I know are living on absolutely nothing.”

Both women were struck by the stark contrast of their lives and, during the swap, they learnt important lessons about the reality of life in poverty.

The programme included a short meeting with Danny Kennedy MLA who chairs the First and Deputy First Ministers’ Committee on Poverty. He believes the target of eradicating poverty by 2020 will be too difficult to meet.

Spotlight reporter Brian Hollywood commented:

"We wanted to give both of these women the chance to express their own anger about poverty and its hidden face. They took a courageous step letting us into the private details of their lives and their experiences are always compelling, sometimes funny, but ultimately very sobering."


BBC Northern Ireland | Editor | 14 Feb 2008
Page Views: 1424


View all News